Furthering efforts to make sure equal alternative to individuals with disabilities, the Supreme Court docket on Thursday requested the Centre to make sure framing of correct tips inside three months to manage and facilitate the grant of scribe facility to candidates whose nature of incapacity imposes a barrier to writing an examination.

A bench of Justices D Y Chandrachud, Indira Banerjee and Sanjiv Khanna stated this whereas holding {that a} civil companies candidate with author’s cramp – dysgraphia – was entitled to a scribe. The courtroom overruled the united states stand that scribe will be offered provided that there was “benchmark incapacity” as set by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment tips underneath The Rights of Individuals with Disabilities Act, 2016.

In the course of the listening to, the ministry took the stand that author’s cramp shouldn’t be particularly included within the checklist of disabilities within the schedule to the Act and accordingly the rules will not be relevant to an individual affected by it.

The SC famous that the ministry has recognised the prevalence of different medical circumstances “not recognized as disabilities per se” however which can hamper the writing functionality of an individual and had left it open to each analyzing physique to think about such instances… in session with the Ministry of Well being and Household Welfare in opposition to the manufacturing of a medical certificates…”

Writing for the bench, Justice Chandrachud termed the “divergent views of two Central Ministries earlier than the Court docket… symptomatic of a coverage disconnect” and added “we specific our disquiet about the truth that, in a coverage matter with profound penalties for India’s disabled inhabitants, the left hand doesn’t know what the precise one is doing”.

The courtroom held that “conflating the rights and entitlements which inhere in individuals with disabilities with the notion of benchmark disabilities does disservice to the salutary function underlying the enactment of the RPwD Act 2016” and “worse nonetheless, to disclaim the rights and entitlements acknowledged for individuals with disabilities on the bottom that they don’t fulfill a benchmark incapacity could be plainly extremely vires the” Act.

The ruling got here on the plea by a 2016 MBBS graduate, Vikash Kumar, who whereas making an attempt civil companies examination in 2017 was offered a scribe however denied the identical in 2018.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here